(photo credit: Tristan Brand)
We can build a beautiful city
Yes, we can; Yes, we can
We can build a beautiful city
Not a city of angels
But we can build a city of man
by Caitlin Murphy
So goes the chorus to a song specifically written for the movie version of Godspell (though often since incorporated into stage versions as well). And so goes the inspiration for the name and mandate of a new Montreal theatre company currently foisting itself into the fray with a production of the 1971 musical. Beautiful City Theatre strikes me as that rare indie company that actually has its shit together.
Which is partly why I feel torn reviewing Godspell. I loved it and hated it. And the distinction lies quite neatly along that divide that musical theatre often unwittingly draws – the play vs. the music. In this case, the play (book by John-Michael Tebelak) is long, meandering, dull and pedantic. The score (music and lyrics by Stephen Schwartz) is at turns joyful, sultry, stirring, foot-stomping, and haunting.